Sorry for the gap

Hi folks

I did write quite a lot a week ago, and it disappeared into the ether, although the photos posted did survive. Well, it’s quite a long time since I added anything new, but the book is progressing!

My sore knee was really sore by the time I got to the end of July (more soon about what I was doing). Without making this a medical treatise, I had suffered several specific injuries to one knee over some years, and had a cartilage operation on it 18 months ago. Went back to my G.P. in late July , saw the same consultant in late August, and was told I needed a partial knee replacement soon, so am on the waiting list. I have no cartilage, or anything else, left between the inner bones in that knee.(so is is painful!).

This led to me having to cancel a planned trip back over to Ireland about now (nice autumn colours for the photos!), but Tony is carrying on, paddling some of the waterways still on our list. I can’t drive much, or walk, or paddle a kayak, or kneel in a canoe, so you can see my limitations.

Back soon

Eddie

April’s Diary

Putting Back on to Shannon

My, time flies – it is now May, I have been over to  N. Ireland, and I have not yet finished writing up the April trip!

I travelled up the Blackwater valley on March 31st – lovely river and scenery, and met two Gardai, who warned me that camping on the river would be challenged, and that the Fermoy to Lismore stretch was heavily guarded due to European Protected Species (so what, we paddle these areas in Scotland?). However, they didn’t say “don’t paddle”.

I spent the next day working my way back to Tony’s house at Maynooth via the Slaney (lovely little river), and the Barrow – see why it’s popular! The day after I looked at both of the main canals, the Grand out to Tullamore, and the Royal to Mullingar.

So, lots of mileage, lots of photos, lots to think about.

Canal Section to Lough Allen

Between May 1st and 5th, I travelled over to N. Ireland with Mike Dales, our SCA Access and Environment Officer, on a trip paid for by a donor for us to find out about how the Irish were tackling Canoe Trails, and their infrastructure and maps and guides. A full account will appear in ‘Scottish Paddler’ due out in July this year, but we had a great time, real hospitality, great practical help (boats lent to us everywhere), and really helpful information. There are currently four trails; Lough Erne, Lower Bann, Lough Neagh, Blackwater, and a fifth to come, Strangford Lough.

We arrived at Belfast international on the Thursday night, and on Friday 2nd, met two colleagues at Toome, and paddled the first part of the Lower Bann. Then saw various points on Lough Neagh (large sheet of water!), and followed the Armagh Blackwater all the way down, lovely little river. After spending the Friday night near Castlewellan, we paddled Strangford on the Saturday, bit of a shock to me after so long away from sea paddling! The inner lough was fine, although the tide runs fast, but the Narrows were running at about 7 knots. A bit interesting in the afternoon, with wind against tide on the ebb.

Liffey Descent 2008

Then we trekked over back west to Fermanagh, to stay two nights with Rob Henshaw, he of four circumnavigations of Ireland (kayak, wind surfer, dinghy, Drascombe), and a recent transatlantic sail. A day and a half on upper Lough Erne – fantastic! – the account and photos will appear in the book, but really superior touring canoe territory.

Since then – a weekend canoe sailing on Coniston, Lake District, and last weekend the Scottish Island Peaks Yacht race – life is just sooo busy!

Comments on the legal access situation in Ireland

I have had many contacts from paddlers in response to my blog on the trip on the Cork Blackwater. Some were Irish, unsure of the actual access situation in Ireland, some from England, or further afield, wishing to establish the real situation before travelling to Ireland on holiday (and spending their hard-earned money!)

For everyone’s information, I set out below the gist of a very helpful e-mail received from Albert Smith, of ‘Keep Ireland Open’, earlier this year. Albert expressed frustration at the uncertain current legal situation, but said the following;

The canoe union of Ireland made a submission to Comhairle na Tuathe (Irish for the Countryside Commission) in January 2006. You will reach it at the following address. Pages four and five deal with access.

Download the sumbmission to Comhairle na Tuathe as a PDF.

Unfortunately, the access issue in Ireland is a fraught mess. Comhairle na Tuathe has proved completely ineffectual at dealing with it – largely because landowners do not see that they have any interest in negotiating with stakeholders who, under the existing dispensation, have virtually no rights and, therefore, nothing to negotiate with.

This suits the farming organisations just fine and, in the absence of any political will to legislate for access, they can afford to say no to virtually everything and get away with it.

Sadly, there is no statute which ‘governs’ access to Irish waters. There is a great hodge-podge of English and Irish judge-made law and a clatter of ancient statutes, which frequently contradict each other. There is no enabling legislation. Indeed, a seminal High Court judgment in 2006 (Lenoach vs Collen) held that there can be no public right of way to any point unless a landowner puts in writing his intention to dedicate it to public use.

This has effectively put all of the custom and practice rights of way in the country (the kind which many canoeists typically enjoy) in jeopardy. Because it was an appeal from the Circuit Court, it could not be further appealed and we (and you) are stuck with it – even though the judge behaved oddly throughout the case, ignored an completely misrepresented key evidence in his judgment and died of a brain tumour shortly afterwards.

The reality is that we are a long way behind both Scotland and England and Wales with regard to access. This did not matter until recent years as there was generally such an easygoing attitude to leisure users that it was seldom a problem. However, that is no longer the case. Access over private land to lakes and river banks, as much as mountains and even ancient monuments, is increasingly a matter for conflict. The canoeist can argue custom and practice but, given the Lenoach judgment, is on shaky ground. What is needed is a complete overhaul of the law. It is for that we in Keep Ireland Open continue to struggle.

You may be able to get a better update on the position on the river bank from the phone numbers attached to the Canoe Union submission.

Sorry if this sounds a bit negative, Eddie, but there is no point in misleading you.

Ireland is a fantastic place for outdoor pursuits. But there is virtually no legal protection for those enjoying them.

I hope this helps people. For those outside of Scotland both interested and curious about our very 21st century situation, I would only add that nothing moved ahead on water until ALL recreation interests agreed to work together, so that the Ramblers etc supported us. Also, we were in a very new political situation, with a great opportunity. As an outsider to Ireland (except my family came from Ireland), I would keep on stressing the financial/tourism advantage of canoeing.

Regards to everyone

Eddie

The Blackwater (Cork)

Well, we’re back, we’ve been to Ireland, paddled the Cork Blackwater (and a lot more) and survived it!

It’s interesting that in 17 days in Ireland (north and south), travelling 2,000 miles, and having been in 26 counties out of the 32, we saw no open canoes on cars, and only 2 vehicles with sea kayaks on.

I wanted to get the Blackwater experience down quickly so that anybody might make comments on it.

The start of the story was in early April when I went up from Waterford for a day to see if there were any obvious difficulties. I had paddled the river as a teenager in either 1964 or 65, on a family holiday when my younger brother and I joined an organised holiday party, run by an Irish company. The Blackwater was obviously at that time both a major river, and a very likely contender for the most popular in Ireland – so what happened? I had tried internet sites during the last year, but found only fishing sites – ominous? I had also spoken to paddlers, e-mailed the ICU, and on this visit gone and spoken to both local people, and also tourist information offices, who had neither information, or knowledge.

(A note here – if we had been told that we couldn’t do something, according to Irish law, we would have respected it – i.e. ‘when in Rome…’ )

At Lismore I met two Guards who were looking into a theft from a car the night before. We chatted for a bit, and they soon told me, not that one could not paddle on the river, but that the area was heavily ‘preserved’, and that camping on the banks was not on – they said that people at night had been removed by them if the landowners (mainly Lismore Estate) accused them of poaching (this being by either people from Cork City, or travellers).

They looked a little bemused about canoeing on the river, but their advice was that it was vehicle parking, plus walking on the land without permission that caused problems. They advised paddling straight through, and only stopping on public land.

So, on Monday June 16th, I met with both Tony, my Irish companion, and three friends from Scotland, at the cottage they had rented for the week at Ballyhooly, between Mallow and Fermoy. Our plan was to do a day above Mallow (this turned out to be right – the river was at a June low, and only possible from Banteer at the highest, (24 km, 16 miles), a day from Mallow to Fermoy, both easy towns to launch from, (33 km, 20.5 miles), and then a long day to go down from Fermoy to Cappoquin (35 km, 22 miles), as I had already determined that both Ballyduff Bridge, and Lismore bridge, on this stretch were impossible to reach the river from.

So, how did we get on? Well, before my moans, let’s recount the good points;

  • All the local people we met were very friendly and helpful, and interested in these strange craft (very few had ever seen an open canoe).
  • The only people we met who were actually angling (four in all!) were OK.
  • There were no ‘No Canoeing’ signs.
  • We called in at the campsite at Fermoy, the only one on the river, and the owner was both helpful, and very interested in having more canoeists – he said he had a small trickle of people paddling calling at his site.
  • Tourist information at Fermoy (closed when I called in April) is run from a fishing tackle shop by an English woman! She was asking for more trade in the valley, and hinted that the area was a bit backward in many ways – the outdoor activities brochure she had for Kerry and Cork has a white water kayaker on the cover!
  • The only points on the river where there is fly fishing (you can see by the strimmed banks) are very limited (out of 92 km!) – 400m at Ballymaquirk bridge at the start, about 800m. between Killavullen and Ballyhooly, and then a few km (2 or 3?), around Ballyduff.

However, we met a real jobsworth at Ballymaquirk Bridge at the start, and all of us were disgusted that this guy, from Yorkshire, kept talking about ‘my river’, ‘my country’ etc. He was a disgrace. Basically, he told us to bugger off, and kept harassing us. (We ended up ignoring him, and refused to talk after a few exchanges).

Amongst the things he said, either to us directly, when three of us were waiting for the other two to do the car shuttle, or to my wife, who luckily had driven them back, and was not leaving a car there (she stayed on the bridge to take photos) were;

  • This was a private river, and he ran that part for the landowner.
  • We would disturb fishing for the whole day (no one was fishing).
  • He got rid of canoeists by persecuting them, and eventually they got the message.
  • It wasn’t an idea to leave vehicles there – they got damaged (we knew already).
  • We were disturbing the gravel in the river (no, we did not), and there were salmon eggs there (no, there wasn’t, this was June!), and this was an offence.
  • ‘Strangers’ were not welcome in these parts - they wanted no visitors (apart from anglers paying to fish, presumably).
  • Canoeing is an extremely environmentally unfriendly activity.

Apparently, as we set off, he used his mobile phone to contact two mates downriver – we met no one (in fact, in three days on the river, we met no one!).

So, it appears for a few measly kilometres of river, if that, one person can frighten off part of the tourist trade, in an area that is palpably poorer than many parts of Ireland, and get away with it!

The river is absolutely beautiful, well worth it, not built up at all.

So, what do you think?

The River Nore

On March 30th, after a restful night spent in Tramore, on the coast near Waterford, we headed north to the River Nore. Rather like the Suir, the upper reaches were shallow with many small weirs, and we settled on Bennettsbridge to start, not Kilkenny. Thomastown, on the way up the valley, had provided a good parking spot, and a pretty little village, although we were going to paddle through to Inistioge, with a handy teashop situated at the egress. The weather was proving kind, good sunshine, and becoming warmer (Scotland was currently under snow back home!).

I hadn’t really said before, but the only guide of any sort we had found to use was the very old ‘BCU Guide to the Waterways of the British Isles’,and the post-war version of 1960s kept refering to information from Ireland in the 1930s! It is quite remarkable that in fact most of the info was correct, and then in some places, as on the Nore, some former weirs, bridges etc. had just disappeared.

We started off in good spirits - warm sunshine, easy to get to the river, an immediate line-down the large weir, whose tail wave would have swamped us. Again, high water and a good current.

The river was kind to us, interesting small rapids, confusing information on obstacles (maybe some were covered), and at a rest at a broken weir (as in photo) two white water racing kayaks bizarrely shot past withuot a word and disappeared. A bit strange that they didn’t say anything, or wave, as we were the only paddlers out!

An unusual apparant broken weir, with two centre concrete bits holding trees, but easy both sides, and then a sharp bend to the left, a small old weir, anglers, and Thomastown appeared. The weir was quite off-putting, fast, with a definite route down the right side, and the need to avoid soem large waves. We managed it fine, shot through the bridge, and then started down the attractive wooded valley to Inistioge.

The valley lived up to expectations, really attractive, and we had a tea break halfway down, with the canoe bobbing about in the fast curent on its tether.

Tea and cakes were consumed after we had done the shuttle. Then, back to Tramore, for another super meal. The surfers were again just returning from the amazing beach at sunset.

Tomorrow, Tony would have a business meeting in Waterford and then return to Dublin, and I would set out to explore the Cork Blackwater in preparation for our summer holidays. The day after, I would work my way back up to Maynooth, and then spend the Wednesday moving ono ut to the Midlands.

So, prospect, photograph, record, and work out when to paddle the water, and where from to where.

( At this same time, back home a detailed canoe trail guide of the Great Glen was appearing on the SCA website - my colleague Mike Dunthorme and I had made it! - we had planned on writing it during January and February, and March for a map to be completed, and the PDF placed on the site.

To view it, go to www.canoescotland.com, then go to ‘Access and environment’, and scroll down)

Meeting Tony

I had met Tony Monaghan, who was to become my co-author, in Kerry, and he came over to Wales for the Open Canoe Symposium last October, held on Lake Bala. The U.K. has a meet every year, shared around between England, Wales and Scotland, and entirely run by volunteers. Wales was eventful – abused by anglers during two days on the Welsh Dee (beautiful river), and then lots of epics on the Tryweryn on the Sunday.

We met again at Christmas 07 in England, to look at maps, and plan the book, the sections, and how to go out and paddle them! (I should of course add that Franco from Pesda had agreed to the idea of the new book).I flew over on March 27th, picked up a car, stayed with Tony at his house in Maynooth, west of Dublin, and we set out the next day to paddle the Suir (tandem, in Tony’s boat)and the Nore, two rivers I had never seen. The other objective was to prospect the Blackwater, and for me to work my way back to Dublin and look at some other waterways.

I should add that Tony is a mad Ray Mears fan, and a very skilled lightweight camper, and this will be highlighted in the book.

Well, what would we find? Would my vague memories from long ago be accurate? Would half-heard stories about access difficulties be correct? What would the weather be like? We headed fast down the motorway to Cork into Tipperary.

Well, we passed the astonishing Rock of Cashel, and having looked at the river at Thurles and downstream, and finding it just too shallow, headed in to Cahir to look for a launch point. Cahir is very scenic, but an impossible weir, and sheer castle walls, and nowhere to park made life difficult. Going further downstream, hoping we would not be pushed too far south, we found, using the OS map, a delightful place kept by the Office of Public Works, Swiss Cottage ( no idea why the house is famous as yet), with a great launch point, and a car park.

Ok, so what about finishing – we drove down to Carrick, via the very busy Clonmel by-pass, this lower valley now quite highly populated, and left the car (all the details in the book).
At last, on the Friday afternoon, on the river! Fast, brown water, lush banks, spring flowers, no one in sight, and lots of small obstructions, easy rapids, little villages, old castles, and a new river. We camped that night on the bank, against a wall of obviously an old estate grounds, with car lights the other side of the river – in the morning, torrential rain, and a horrible high wind for a few hours. Waiting until the wind died down, we paddled in a more steep-sided wooded valley , and then finally into Clonmel, being welcomed by the friendly rowing club and skiffs whizzing by.

The steep weir was a right laugh, the obvious left side for a short portage blocked by trees. We finally managed it with Tony grabbing the canoe being paddled gingerly by me right on the lip of the weir, hauling me in, and then carrying down through the thicket at the side. Fast water followed, then the miles to Carrick, through pleasant countryside, more castles and grand houses, and a finish at the tidal limit.

The next day, the Nore! What would this bring?

Author’s Irish blog

Eddie on Loch Maree

Hi folks,
This is the first post for ‘Irish Canoe Classics’, having made my first trip over to Ireland paddling for many years during the last week, so events are fresh in my mind.

The idea for this came from new Irish friends at the Canoe Symposium held in May last year at Cappanalea, Co. Kerry, very well organised by Lorcan O’Donnell. My ‘Scottish Canoe Classics’ had only just been published by Pesda Press, and I was looking forward to a rest!

It came out of me saying that I wanted to return to Ireland to paddle the Cork Blackwater again, having done (most of) it with my younger brother in either 1963 or 64. (the Blackwater will feature greatly in the next few months!). The idea formed slowly in my mind, as I chatted to Irish paddlers about what should go in to a book that celebrated the 25 or 30 best, most enjoyable, most beautiful, routes in Ireland, on the same basis as my Scottish book, that is;

  • They would be flat, or Grade 1 or 2 water
  • Providing at least a day-long paddle, preferably more.
  • Portages would be kept to a minimum, and would be an easy walk-round (no Grade 6 gorges!)
  • There would be information on access and egress, and campsites, and good maps
  • There would be some background on the area, on the history, geography and politics

Why, you may ask?

Well, our experience in Scotland is that this is what the vast majority of the public want – easy to access water, with no hassle – a simple to understand guide. The wider context is that where and when there have been access problems, or unsympathetic developments, for instance new building blocking off an access point, it is simply because canoeing and kayaking have been not known about, or understood, and more publicity is badly needed.

To be continued …

Eddie Palmer